Classic Rarities LLC
71 Main St
Hamburg, NY 14075
(716) 863-9099

Classic Rarities, LLC

Buying Rare Coins & Old Currency

Top Prices Paid Call 716-863-9099 Today!

Rare Coin Dealers in Buffalo, NY

LP2 John Magavern is a successful silver and gold coin dealer. For over 24 years he has been active in the rare coin market and made a career as one of the leading coin dealers in Buffalo. As one of the top rare coin dealers in the area, John Magavern is certified in grading coins by the American Numismatic Association. He's purchased millions of dollars worth of the rare coins from thousands of satisfied customers! If you're looking for quality coin dealers in the Buffalo area, don't hesitate to call us today!

Buying your silver and gold coins and fair prices!

John Magavern, owner of Classic Rarities, is nationally recognized for his dedication to honest and professional dealings of gold jewelry, rare currency and silver and gold coins. After dealing with a large network of rare coin dealers, and attending numerous coin shows, he has obtained the knowledge necessary to run a successful Rare Coin business.He is a Member of the ANA (Life), FUN, CSNA, GSNA, Buffalo Numismatic Association and the Society of Silver Dollar Collectors (Life).  

John deals nationally with a large network of dealers and collectors allowing him to pay you Top Dollar for your coin or entire collection.  John offers both timely and courteous service with immediate payment.  He attends most major shows across the US. Specializing in rare early U.S. Gold and Silver coins (pre 1964). John is well respected both locally and nationally within the numismatic communit. Let John Magavern of Classic Rarities apply his extensive experience and knowledge to the purchase of your silver and gold coins.

Present John with your...

  • 1964 and earlier U.S. half dollars, dimes and quartersCoin Dealers Buffalo
  • silver and gold coins
  • silver dollars from 1935 and earlier 
  • U.S. mint products
  • old coin albums
  • proof and mint sets
  • commemoratives
  • foreign coins
  • wheat pennies
  • silver and gold eagles
  • copper coins
  • Kennedy halves from 65-70, gold
  • silver and sterling bars
  • gold jewelry and other rare coins and currency

Rare Coin Dealers Buffalo  John Magavern: Professional Numismatist

Call to make your appointment today!


Memberships and affiliations:

ANA American Numismatic Association - Life Member 5731 
PCGSsmall Professional Coin Grading Service
ngclogo Numismatic Guaranty Corporation

Florida United Numismatists

csnslogo copy

Central States Numismatic Society


Garden State Numismatic Association


Society of Silver Dollar Collectors - Life Member


Buffalo Numismatic Association

"At Classic Rarities, you will be paid in cash immediately after the purchase. Appraisals are performed at an hourly rate and are free if your items are bought. We will liquidate your coin collection as an entire purchase or on consignment at an agreed commission rate and will submit your raw coins to a grading service for quality encapsulation and he provides affordable consultations. Don’t miss out with one of the greatest coin dealers around in WNY. Call or visit us today!"

 Silver and Gold Coins Buffalo STOP Coin Dealers Buffalo

“Coin and Gold Sellers Beware!” 

*Beware of these out of town buyers setting up at local hotels claiming to pay the most for your coins. They’re worth a lot more than what most of them pay. Don’t be fooled by the urgency and deception of their ads. I know one weekend I was paying 30 times face value for pre 1965 silver coins while they were paying 20 times face when silver was $48+ (That’s 10X More). They may be here for the weekend, but I’m always here! No one advertising to buy your valuables should ever ask what you want for them. They should tell you what they’ll pay you for them. It’s their way of avoiding paying you too much for them, as well as judging your knowledge of the item(s). Always GET A SECOND OPINION FROM A LOCAL DEALER! 

Rare Coin Dealers Buffalo

Products & Services

Buying U.S. Coins & Currency, Morgan Dollars, Peace Dollars, pre 1964 90% Silver Dimes, Silver Quarters and Silver Half Dollars, Buying Rare Gold Coins, Silver Coins and Copper Coins, Gold and Silver Bullion, As Well As Old Currency, Large Size notes, Silver Certificates, Gold Certificates etc., Buffalo Coin Dealer Buying Silver Coins Pre 1964, Also Buying Patterns, Proof, sets & Mints sets as well as Commemoratives, and all other mint products.

Buffalo Coin Dealer...Serving Buffalo and all of western New York as well as Northern Pennsylvania.  Offering Expert Estate Appraisals...... I will submit your better date or quality coins for Grading by The Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) and American Numismatic Association Certification Service (ANACS)

Coin dealer Buffalo, New York and the surrounding areas, I'm a professional numismatist and certified in grading coins by the American Numismatic Association, I'm always Buying U.S. Coins & currency with top prices paid, specializing in rare early US gold and silver coins (pre 1964), immediate cash payment, timely and courteous service, Monday - Saturday 10-6 by appointment, evening hours upon request, attending most major shows across the US.

Be the first to review this business!

Review today and interact with local businesses in your area. Tell us your experiences and share them with others. It's easy!

Click to select your destination

How Can We Help?
Thank you! Your message was sent!
Hours of Operation:

Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY and the surrounding areas located in Hamburg, NY Evening Hours by request.... APPOINTMENTS ONLY ! Please call with any Questions

Brands Carried:

Coin Dealer Buffalo New York, Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY, Coin Dealer Buffalo and surrounding areas, Coin Dealer Hamburg New York, Buying coins in Buffalo NY, Buying coins in Buffalo New York, Buying coins in Hamburg NY, Buying Rare Coins in Buffalo and surrounding areas. Rare coins Buffalo New York, Rare Coins Buffalo NY, Buffalo coin dealers



  • American Numismatic Association (Life)

  • Florida United Numismatists
  • Central States Numismatic Association
  • Garden State Numismatic Association
  • Buffalo Numismatic Association
  • Society of Silver Dollar Collectors (Life) as well as being an Authorized dealer for the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation all in great standings.